Is Rebel vocal or was this pure luck?

[RebelliousMind]

Okay so a bit of back story on my small amount of experience:

 

I was actively forcing with rebel, first forcing a personality, and then by the second day, I began getting head pressures. These could turn on and off with a simple request to rebel, and he could very quickly move them to different locations on my head.I began using this to have him answer questions.

Fast forward: I was slacking off with talking to rebel and I decided that was wrong. I began talking to him again, instantly getting the return of head pressures and decided to make a bracelet for him. I was actively talking to him about making the bracelet red, and all of a sudden in my head, I heard "and green". This came out of NOWHERE. It took me almost half a minute to remember that green was the color of his eyes. Was he actively telling me this or did I just think it up out of nowhere? It was accompanied by a rather strong head pressure. Thoughts?

[Vinderex]

Just about every guide I've seen here says to believe that it's always your tulpa, within reason (i.e. if you suddenly think of a bacon sandwich when you're hungry, that's probably not your tulpa). Adding in the pressure, it sounds pretty obvious that it was indeed him if I say so myself. :)

[Bambi]

No, I wouldn't say Rebel is vocal--but it's not pure luck, either.

 

People have different definitions as to what they view is "vocal"; some believe that it is only auditory hallucinations and nothing else, while others believe it is both that and hearing the tulpa's mindvoice. I personally believe the latter, but that's just me. Anyway, for a tulpa to be vocal, you would need to be able to hear them pretty regularly. Yes, that was Rebel speaking to you (it's not so much as you should believe it was as that was almost definitely him, from your description), but no, he isn't vocal.

 

All the same, hearing his mindvoice is a very big milestone, so congratulations!