1 year, still no reply from my tulpa

[Raetin]

 

I am only Narrating to my tulpa.

and whit reply i mean mindvoice.

 

Like Chupi said, sitting down to actively force might be a more efficient way of getting progress. The few months I only narrated with my tulpa recently had no progress. That said, I only chatted here and there, with much of my focus on other things. Not for everyone, you know. I recommend active forcing. It produces results, in most cases, because it forces you to focus.

[Pepper]

If you didn't have any interaction... how do you know the tulpa is there?

[The-Syreth-Clan]

Martina and I have the same issue, she still can't talk, however she can use body language. It's usually just her nodding or shaking her head, and other emotions, usually cutting into my sentences to show it is her doing. She didn't even use head pressures until Kaga pointed it out just now, but she is doing it again now. Guess she just forgot about it? *Martina nods rather awkwardly*

[Masonlahd]

Not quite sure if you're having trouble with hearing her through your mind voice or audibly. With the mind voice, your tulpae, should respond through thought so it'll almost seem like you're talking to yourself. But with hearing your tulpa audibly... That's another story. You're literally tricking your mind into hearing something that actually isn't there, so you must be aware how involved and hard it can be to acomplish this phenomena. Best wishes to you both!

[ThunderClap]

Don't worry so much about time, there is no set time frame for these things to happen. It took Placidia over a year to become fully vocal. She said if she can offer any advice at all to hosts struggling with this, it would be to "listen" for a response. I know that sounds a bit abstract, but sometimes tulpas can communicate with you in ways that you do not expect, beyond just emotions and words. It is important to feel how your tulpa might respond to you, and try to get a sense of them as a person instead of what they're speaking, vocally. Sorry if that sounds vague or abstract, it is a very difficult concept to explain. Don't expect full auditory hallucinations right off the bat, that comes with imposition.